
DAVAO CITY (MindaNews / 20 November 2026) – A defense witness on Friday told the Senate impeachment court he could not explain the huge disparity between the inward remittances to CALE88 Foods Corp., a banana chip-producing firm partly owned by Vice President Sara Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, and the export sales the company declared to the Board of Investments (BOI).
The foreign remittances amounting to P767 million, P315 million of which reportedly came from China, was contained in a transaction report from the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) earlier presented by the prosecution panel.
Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian noted that CALE88 declared sales revenues amounting to P208 million from 2022 to 2025 to the BOI fell far below the foreign remittances.
Gatchalian asked Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, the defense witness, to explain the reasons for the discrepancy.
Rodolfo replied he could not explain why the inward remittances exceeded the declared sales revenues of the corporation.
Senator-Judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson said there was no doubt as to CALE88’s legitimacy as a corporation or its compliance with regulatory requirements.
Lacson, however, noted that the “meat of the issue” was the possibility that the company was being used for money laundering or as a medium for inward remittances.
“What we want to see is proof or records like waybills, shipping records. I know you said earlier that those are with (Bureau of) Customs, but we are all wondering if the defense has them to refute the forensic financial analysis, just to erase our doubts that CALE88 might have been used,” he said.
Defense counsel Michael Poa assured the impeachment court that they would present evidence at a proper time to refute these claims.
Rodolfo was presented to testify, among others, on the registration of CALE88 with BOI as proof of its being a legitimate producer and exporter of banana chips, defense counsel Justin Nicol Gular said.
Senator-Judge Risa Hontiveros also noted the disparity in CALE88’s declaration to BOI and inward remittances flagged by the AMLC.
The disparity in the reports was surprising, Hontiveros said.
She questioned how CALE88, registered as a micro, small, and medium enterprise, could produce banana chips in large volumes.
“Going back to your bureau’s annual reports, companies are also required to report updated production and performance data, including sales as well as this foreign remittance. Based on CALE88’s business standing, isn’t it surprising that ₱770 million coming in from abroad was flagged by the AMLC?” she asked.
The AMLC report, Rodolfo admitted, did not match their own record.
“It won’t match our records of what should be coming in,” he said.
Hontiveros noted that the company reported 422,722 kilograms of banana chips produced in 2025, a volume she estimated would require 1,900 metric tons of bananas annually.
Rodolfo, however, said the corporation’s actual production was within its plant’s total capacity of 1.18 million kilograms of bananas.
“Actually, Usec (Rodolfo), it sounds bananas. We don’t even need to say whether it’s plausible or implausible. Given the size of the company, the number of workers, and the size of the factory, can it really handle that scale of production?” Hontiveros asked.
The defense witness replied that he could not answer, as he had not visited CALE88’s factory himself.
Senator-Judge Bam Aquino likewise questioned the glaring disparity between the BOI report and transaction report from AMLC.
“What I don’t understand is the AMLC inflow mentioned earlier by Senators Sherwin and Risa. At least P700 million came in, of which P315 million came from China, which has been discussed, yet only P208 million was declared as earnings. And you cannot hazard a guess as to how that happened?” Aquino asked.
Rodolfo pointed out that the corporation had no other declared sources of revenues.
“All I can say, based on their operations and based on their declaration to us, is that they have no other source of income other than this operation. So if you ask me what should be coming in to them, it is only this amount. As to other sources, I would be purely guessing,” he said. (Antonio L. Colina IV / MindaNews)








