
ZAMBOANGA CITY (MindaNews / 22 November 2026) — A bitter irony in public life: people who campaign against corruption, injustice, and discrimination can, once in office, defend the very arrangements that keep communities excluded. A promise of service means little if public decisions still reward patronage, concentrate power, and leave farmers, fisherfolk, and Indigenous communities with the costs. This is more than a failure of character. It is a failure of governance — and in conflict-affected parts of Mindanao, governance failures shape whether people experience peace as a daily reality or only as a document signed elsewhere.
Mindanao’s conflicts cannot be reduced to a religious divide: one analysis frames them as questions of historical and structural injustice and warns that the Christian–Muslim lens can obscure Lumad marginalization (Maboloc, 2024). Land remains both a root of conflict and a possible basis for longer-term resolution (Tuminez, 2007). A municipal-level analysis of violence in the former Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao found that armed clashes were more frequent where local government was weak, and access to services, education, and land was poor; its case studies linked these conditions to declining confidence in state authority (Gonzales, 2017). These findings do not make poverty a sufficient explanation for violence. They show why peace efforts that leave material and political grievances untouched remain vulnerable.
Land is central to that unfinished work: research describes it as both a root of conflict and a potential basis for long-term resolution (Tuminez, 2007). It carries livelihood, identity, authority and memory; it is not simply a resource to allocate after negotiations. Recent mixed-methods research in Mindanao finds that ancestral-domain areas are less likely to experience general conflict but more likely to experience land-related conflict, and that titling does not automatically resolve disputes: delayed administration is associated with the continuation of land conflict (Madrigal et al., 2025). Another recent analysis argues that Lumad communities have been excluded from key Bangsamoro peace negotiations and that their ancestral-domain claims remain insufficiently protected (Bayot, 2026). The lesson is not that autonomy or peace agreements are without value. Rather, a settlement cannot be called inclusive if one people’s self-determination is advanced while another’s remains unresolved.
The work of peace therefore extends beyond formal talks. Grassroots organizations and community peace advocates have helped address local feuds, monitor ceasefires, protect civilians, engage women in peacebuilding, and counter violent extremism (Cesar, 2020). In one community-level Peace and Conflict Impact Assessment, feuding families took responsibility for settling rido-related violence, while women — often rendered invisible in a patriarchal setting — proved essential to the process. These efforts matter because they create practical ways to restore relationships and resolve disputes in communities. They should complement, not excuse, the state’s responsibility to protect rights, deliver services, and ensure fair decisions.
Nor should “community-based” be treated as a synonym for automatic fairness. Local customs and dialogue can sustain trust, but who gets to speak, whose land claim is recognized, and who controls resources still matter. Women’s participation may be indispensable without being equal; Indigenous claims may be recognized in principle yet neglected in implementation. Peacebuilding must make room for women, young people, and Indigenous communities not merely as beneficiaries or witnesses, but as decision-makers. A local mechanism’s test is not its age or cultural label; it is whether it protects dignity, handles disagreement accountably, and resists coercion or elite capture.
Climate stress makes this test more urgent: participatory research in Mindanao found that climate impacts can weaken community capacity and interact with existing conflict (Medina et al., n.d.). In conflict-prone farming communities in Mindanao, a study based on 14 focus groups and 77 interviews found that climate pressures and conflict together harmed livelihoods, assets, agricultural yields, and household finances. It also found gendered effects: women farmers faced smaller plots, food insecurity, discrimination, and loss of customary land rights (Chandra et al., 2017). A climate-security pathway analysis for the Philippines identifies competition over land and water and livelihood and food insecurity as routes through which climate variability can intensify existing vulnerabilities; these are pathways of risk, not evidence that climate change mechanically causes armed conflict. A participatory appraisal in three Mindanao localities similarly found that climate impacts and unevenly distributed resilience benefits could weaken community capacity and deepen distrust (Medina et al., n.d.).
That is why climate adaptation is also a question of justice. Philippine community case studies describe transformative climate justice through inclusion, respect for different forms of knowledge, and the restoration of communities and ecosystems — and stress that it requires a deliberate redistribution of decision-making power (See et al., 2024). Adaptation planned without those safeguards can repeat old exclusions under the language of resilience. When planned with communities, it can protect livelihoods, recognize local knowledge, and create shared reasons to cooperate. Food, water, secure land, and dignified work are not soft additions to peace and security; they are conditions that make peace durable.
Structural reform must link these local realities to accountable public institutions. Protecting ancestral-domain and land rights goes beyond issuing titles: it requires timely implementation, accessible dispute resolution, and safeguards for overlapping claims. Local governments need the capacity and resources to deliver services transparently, while communities need meaningful influence over development priorities and climate spending. Transitional justice must acknowledge past harms and include those excluded from earlier settlements. Farmers and fisherfolk should be treated as rights-holders and partners in policy design, not as recipients of short-term assistance. These are not technical adjustments at the edges of peace; they are choices about whose security the state is organized to protect.
Public servants who speak on behalf of the marginalized should be judged by whether their decisions reduce exclusion. Peace cannot be measured solely by the silence of guns or the survival of an agreement. It must also be felt in whether families can remain on their land, earn a living, participate without fear, and obtain a fair hearing when their rights are contested. The path from betrayal to peace is not rhetorical. It is the hard work of sharing power, repairing harm, and changing the structures that sustain vulnerability.
(MindaViews is the opinion section of MindaNews. Maudi Maadil (a.k.a Algazelus) is a dedicated advocate for human rights and a humanitarian with over 14 years of experience working on diverse projects and programs focused on peace, security, and stability in Mindanao. He established ProVolve Skills Bridge Inc., and is an alumnus of the 2024 Western Union Foundation Fellowship, supported by the Watson Institute, as well as the Geneva Centre for Security Policy. Email address: [email protected])








